Baldy's Pizzeria

Discover Baldy's Pizzeria in Bloomington, IN — your favorite local Italian restaurant offering delicious pizza, stromboli, breadsticks, and more. Enjoy fast delivery, dine-in, or takeout in a casual, family-friendly atmosphere. Accepts reservations and multiple payment options. Call +1 812-824-3555 today!

View MenuMake a Reservation

Welcome to Baldy's Pizzeria

Taste the Difference.

Baldy's Pizzeria
Baldy's Pizzeria
Baldy's Pizzeria
Baldy's Pizzeria

Nestled in the heart of Bloomington, Indiana, Baldy's Pizzeria offers a warm, casual spot to enjoy authentic Italian and American comfort foods. Since opening at 4017 S Old State Rd 37, we’ve built a loyal following, known for our quick service, hearty pizzas, and welcoming vibe. Whether you're stopping in for a quick lunch, a family dinner, or a late-night craving, Baldy's provides quality food in a friendly atmosphere. Our menu features local specialties, including hand-tossed pizzas, stromboli, breadsticks, and more. We accept reservations to accommodate groups and families, and our wheelchair-accessible facilities ensure everyone can enjoy our dishes comfortably. With a reputation for generous portions and affordable prices, we aim to be your go-to spot for satisfying food and genuine hospitality in Bloomington.

Directions & Reservations

Plan Your Visit

Address

4017 S Old State Rd 37, Bloomington, IN 47401, United States

Phone

+1 812-824-3555

Social Media

About

The Culinary Story

Baldy's Pizzeria
Baldy's Pizzeria
Baldy's Pizzeria
Baldy's Pizzeria

Baldy's Pizzeria is a cornerstone of Bloomington’s food scene, dedicated to serving authentic Italian and American comfort foods since day one. Our kitchen churns out large, flavorful pizzas topped with fresh ingredients, such as premium sausage, ham, and locally sourced BBQ chicken. Our stromboli and sub sandwiches are crafted with care, and our breadsticks are famous in town for their perfect crunch and flavor. We operate with a focus on quality, speed, and customer satisfaction, which is evident in the glowing reviews and repeat visits from local residents.

We’re proud to serve a community that values good food and good company, often transforming a simple meal into a memorable experience. Throughout the week, our menu varies from traditional favorites to innovative dishes, including vegan options that cater to diverse tastes. Whether you’re a Bloomington native or just passing through, Baldy's feels like home—where every slice counts.

Work Hours

Availability and Service Times

  • SundayOpen
  • MondayOpen
  • TuesdayOpen
  • WednesdayOpen
  • ThursdayOpen
  • FridayOpen
  • SaturdayOpen

Baldy's Pizzeria stands out with its fast service and delicious offerings. We serve a diverse menu suited for lunch and dinner, including specialty pizzas like Hawaiian and Triple Cheeseburger, hot sandwiches such as stromboli and ham & cheese, and crispy side orders like breadsticks and fiery chicken strips. Our friendly staff provides table service in a cozy, casual setting that’s perfect for families, groups, or solo visits.

With amenities including wheelchair accessibility, kids’ high chairs, and a convenient parking lot, Baldy's ensures a hassle-free dining experience. We also offer delivery and takeaway options, so you can enjoy our hot, fresh food at home. Price-wise, our meals range from $10 to $20, making us an affordable choice for a hearty meal any day of the week.

Baldy's Pizzeria

Our restaurant’s exterior is welcoming, with ample free street parking and a wheelchair-accessible entrance that invites everyone in. The outdoor vibe is casual and laid-back, perfect for an informal hangout. Bright signage and a cozy porch setting give Baldy's a friendly face in Bloomington. Inside, the atmosphere remains cozy and quiet, making it ideal for both family outings and solo dining. During warmer months, enjoy your meal al fresco in our outdoor seating area, soaking up the Indiana sun while savoring your favorite slice. The friendly, community-oriented spirit is felt from the moment you arrive, making Baldy's not just a pizza spot but a neighborhood gathering place.

Guestbook & Reviews

Experience Through Their Eyes

New location, same great food! Always count on pizza to be delicious and breadsticks are our favorite. Best stromboli in town hands down! Prices are fair and staff is always super nice.

D
Dubqueen20

Grate team, working hard for some of the best pizza. In town hands down. Dont hesitate to get extra cheese and sauce 😋 it was amazing 2 large pizzas, 39$ was a good bargain. Grate job , keep up the good work, ill be back😎 they are doing suck a grate job, their is wait times, so order ahead, for more convenience. 💯

J
Jeffrey

I went here for brunch with a friend and her daughter yesterday. I was pleasantly surprised to see that there was a vegan veggie burger on the menu(win!) I didn't order it though so I can't comment on how that dish is. If you look at the menu, you'll see that their menu changes M-F, which I think is pretty cool. I ended up ordering a grilled cheese, with some added 🥑. Our waitress was super friendly; I can't recall her name, but she said that serving us was her second time working as a waitress, since she'd been a busser before, but had been promoted; she genuinely seemed happy, which is great. For me, the happiness of the workers does factor in my reviews, fyi. We ordered and our food came out all at once in about ten minutes; when it did, we all remarked at how large the portions were. My friend and her daughter ordered some kind of sandwich, the one that comes with the au jus dip(sorry can't remember the name of the meat), and the chicken tenders. All of us thoroughly enjoyed our food, and I especially liked the way they cooked their fries; crispy on the edges but soft on the inside. They were also really thick. My grilled cheese wasn't soggy, maintained it's crispiness throughout and the Swiss cheese was of quality and super tasty. I also appreciate the avocado was actually a good 🥑, because usually when I order avocado with a sandwich they cheap out on those at restaurants and get the watery ones. My friend's daughter also ordered a strawberry milkshake; it was delivered to her with an additional metal cup that contained extra, which was pretty much almost enough for two milkshakes; the guy who served it to us offered to put in a separate cup and add whipped cream on top for my friend, which was really considerate. Overall, the food and the friendly service persons here would definitely bring me back if I'm in the area again, I would highly recommend!

J
Jinji S.

This is the type of place where you can go with family or meet up with friends. The food is amazingly delicious which explains the wait times if they take a little longer then usual, but the food is well worth the wait. Service is excellent with the utmost respect shown to their customers. I recommend Baldy's to all my friends and family.

S
Stephan S.

Awesome pizza and breadsticks!! We got some food delivered to Bloomington Speedway for Indiana Sprint Week. Recommend this place, we’ll be ordering from them when we’re back in town.

B
Blake B.

A great pizza place that I will return to next time in Bloomington. Bread stick are to die for- the best. Sausage is really good and tasty. Veggie had a ton of toppings. Reasonably priced.

J
Jeffrey S.